PAIN
Volume 130, Issue 1 , Pages 157-165 , July 2007

Efficacy of electrical nerve stimulation for chronic musculoskeletal pain: A meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials

  • Michael Johnson

      Affiliations

    • Philosopher’s River Consultancy, Willow Creek, MT 59760, USA
    • ,
  • Melissa Martinson

      Affiliations

    • Institute of Health Policy and Management, University of Minnesota, Minneapolis, MN, USA
    • Princeton Reimbursement Group, 7650 Edinborough Way Suite 550 Minneapolis, MN 55435, USA
    • Corresponding Author InformationCorresponding author. Address: Princeton Reimbursement Group, 9801 DuPont Avenue S., Suite 295, Minneapolis, MN 55431, USA. Tel.: +1 952 345 6404; fax: +1 952 345 6410.

Received 8 September 2006 ,Revised 13 February 2007 ,Accepted 13 February 2007.

References 

  1. Albright J, Allman R, Bonfiglio RP, Conill A, Dobkin B, Guccione AA, et al. Philadelphia panel evidence-based clinical practice guidelines on selected rehabilitation interventions for neck pain. Phys Ther. 2001;81:1701–1718
  2. Albright J, Allman R, Bonfiglio RP, Conill A, Dobkin B, Guccione AA, et al. Philadelphia panel evidence-based clinical practice guidelines on selected rehabilitation interventions for low back pain. Phys Ther. 2001;81:1641–1674
  3. Albright J, Allman R, Bonfiglio RP, Conill A, Dobkin B, Guccione AA, et al. Philadelphia panel evidence-based clinical practice guidelines on selected rehabilitation interventions for knee pain. Phys Ther. 2001;81:1675–1700
  4. Albright J, Allman R, Bonfiglio RP, Conill A, Dobkin B, Guccione AA, et al. Philadelphia panel evidence-based clinical practice guidelines on selected rehabilitation interventions: overview and methodology. Phys Ther. 2001;81:1629–1640
  5. Bjordal J, Johnson M, Ljunggreen A. Transcutaneous electrical nerve stimulation (TENS) can reduce postoperative analgesic consumption. A meta-analysis with assessment of optimal treatment parameters for postoperative pain. Eur J Pain. 2003;7:181–188
  6. Breau RH, Carnat TA, Gabory I. Inadequate statistical power of negative clinical trials in urological literature. J Urol. 2006;176:263–266
  7. Brosseau L, Yonge K, Marchand S. Transcutaneous electrical nerve stimulation for the treatment of rheumatoid arthritis in the hand. The Cochrane Library. 2004;1–17
  8. Brosseau L, Miline S, Marchand S, Robinson V, Shea B, Wells G, et al. Efficacy of the transcutaneous electrical nerve stimulation for the treatment of chronic low back pain. Spine. 2002;27:596–603
  9. Carroll D, Moore R, McQuay H. Transcutaneous electrical nerve stimulation (TENS) for chronic pain. The Cochrane Library. 2004;1:1–42
  10. Chee EK, Walton H. Treatment of trigger points with microamperage transcutaneous electrical nerve stimulation (TENS)-(Thr Electro-Acuscope 80). J Manipulative Physiol Ther. 1986;9:131–134
  11. Deeks J, Higgins J, Riis J, Silagy C. Cochrane collaboration open learning material for Cochrane Reviewers, <http://www.cochrane-net.org/openlearning/HTML/mod0.htm>.
  12. Deyo RA, Walsh NE, Schoenfeld LS, Ramamurthy S. Can trials of physical treatments be blinded?. Am J Phys Med & Rehabil. 1990;69:6–10
  13. Edwards JE, McQuay JH, Moore RA. Efficacy and safety of valdecoxib for treatment of osteoarthritis and rheumatoid arthritis: systematic review of randomised controlled trials. Pain. 2004;111:286–296
  14. Elia N, Tramer MR. Ketamine and postoperative pain – a quantitative systematic review of randomised trials. Pain. 2005;113:61–70
  15. Fargas-Babjak A, Rooney P, Gerecz E. Randomized trial of codetron for pain control in osteoarthritis of the hip/knee. Clin J Pain. 1989;5:137–141
  16. Fishbain DA, Chabal C, Abbott A, Wipperman Heine L, Cutler R. Transcutaneous electrical nerve stimulation (TENS) treatment outcome in long-term users. Clin J Pain. 1996;12:201–214
  17. Jadad A. Assessing the quality of reports of randomized clinical trials: is blinding necessary. Control Clin Trials. 1996;17:1–12
  18. Khadikar A, Milne S, Brosseau L, Wells G, Tugwell P, Robinson V, et al. Transcutaneous electrical nerve stimulation for the treatment of chronic low back pain: a systematic review. Spine. 2005;30:2657–2666
  19. Lipsey MW, Wilson DB. Practical Meta-Analysis. London: Sage Publications; 2001;
  20. Long DM. Fifteen years of transcutaneous electrical stimulation for pain control. Stereotact Funct Neurosurg. 1991;56:2–19
  21. Melzack R, Vetire P, Finch L. Transcutaneous electrical nerve stimulation for low back pain: a comparison of TENS and massage for pain and range of motion. Phys Ther. 1983;63:489–493
  22. Melzack R, Wall P. Pain mechanisms: a new theory. Science. 1965;150:971–979
  23. Milne S, Welch V, Brosseau L, Saginur M, Shea B, Tugwell P, et al. Transcutaneous electrical nerve stimulation (TENS) for chronic low back pain (Cochrane Review). In: The Cochrane Library, 2002. Oxford: Update Software.
  24. Moher D, Cook D, Eastwood S, Olkin I, Rennie D, Stroup D. Improving the quality of reports of meta-analyses of randomised controlled trials: the QUORUM statement. Lancet. 1999;354:1896–1900
  25. Osiri M, Welch V, Brosseau L, Shea B, McGowan J, Tugwell P, et al. Transcutaneous electrical nerve stimulation for knee osteoarthritis (Cochrane Review). In: The Cochrane Library, 2002. Oxford: Update Software.
  26. Price P. Electrical stimulation for preventing and treating post-stroke shoulder pain: a systematic cochrane review. Clin Rehabil. 2001;15:5–19
  27. Sjolund B, Eriksson M. Electro-acupuncture and endogenous morphines. Lancet. 1976;1085
  28. Woolf CJ, Bennett GJ, Doherty M, Dubner R, Kidd B, Koltzenburg M, et al. Towards a mechanism-based classification of pain?. Pain. 1998;77:227–229
    Included randomized trials
  1. Abelson K, Langley GB, Sheppeard H, Vlieg M, Wigley RD. Transcutaneous electrical nerve stimulation in rheumatoid arthritis. N Z Med J. 1983;9:156–158
  2. Cheing T, Lo H-C. Optimal stimulation duration of tens in the management of osteoarthritic knee pain. Rehabil Med. 2003;35:62–68
  3. Cheing GLY, Hui-Chan CWY, Chan KM. Does four weeks of TENS and/or isometric exercise produce cumulative reduction of osteoarthritic knee pain?. Clin Reahabil. 2002;16:749–760
  4. Cheing GL, Hui-Chan CW. Transcutaneous electrical nerve stimulation: nonparallel antinociceptive effects on chronic clinical pain and acute experimental pain. Arch Phys Med Rehabil. 1999;80:305–312
  5. Defrin R, Efrat A, Chava P. Segmental noxious versus innocuous electrical stimulation for chronic pain relief and the effect of fading sensation during treatment. Pain. 2005;115:152–160
  6. Deyo RA, Walsh NE, Martin DC, Schoenfeld LS, Ramamurthy S. A controlled trial of transcutaneous electrical nerve stimulation (TENS) and exercise for chronic low back pain. New Engl J Med. 1990;322:1627–1634
  7. Fargas-Babjak AM, Pomeranz B, Rooney PJ. Acupuncture-like stimulation with codetron for rehabilitation of patients with chronic pain syndrome and osteoarthritis. Acupunct Electrother Res Int J. 1992;17:95–105
  8. Gemignani G, Olivieri I, Ruju G, Pasero G. Transcutaneous electrical nerve stimulation in ankylosing spondylitis: a double-blind study. Arthritis Rheum. 1991;34:788–789
  9. Ghoname E, Craig W, White P. The effect of stimulus frequency on the analgesic response to percutaneous electrical nerve stimulation in patients with chronic low back pain. Anesth Analg. 1999;88:841–846
  10. Ghoname E, Craig W, White P. Percutaneous electrical nerve stimulation for low back pain. JAMA. 1999;281:818–823
  11. Graff-Radford SB, Reeves JL, Baker RL, Chiu D. Effects of transcutaneous electrical nerve stimulation on myofascial pain and trigger point sensitivity. Pain. 1989;37:1–5
  12. Hamza M, White P, Ahmed H. Effect of the frequency of transcutaneous electrical nerve stimulation on the postoperative opioid analgesic requirement and recovery profile. Anesthesiology. 1999;91:132–1238
  13. Hsueh T, Cheng P, Kuan T. The immediate effectiveness of electrical nerve stimulation and electrical muscle stimulation on myofascial trigger points. Am J Phys Med Rehabil. 1997;76:471–476
  14. Jarzem PF, Harvey EJ, Arcaro N, Kaczorowski J. Transcutaneous electrical nerve stimulation [TENS] for short-term treatment of low back pain-randomized double blind cross-over study of sham versus conventional TENS. J Musculoskel Pain. 2005;13:11–17
  15. Langley GB, Sheppeard H, Johnson M, Wigley RD. The analgesic effects of transcutaneous electrical nerve stimulation and placebo in chronic pain patients. Rheumatol Int. 1984;4:199;123
  16. Law PPW, Cheing GLY. Optimal stimulation frequency of transcutaneous electrical nerve stimulation on people with knee osteoarthritis. J Rehabil Med. 2004;36:220–225
  17. Lehmann TR, Russell DW, Spratt KF, Colby H, King-Liu Y, Fairchild ML, et al. Efficacy of electroacupuncture and TENS in the rehabilitation of chronic low back pain patients. Pain. 1986;26:277–290
  18. Lewis B, Lewis D, Cumming G. The comparative analgesic efficacy of transcutaneous electrical nerve stimulation and a non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drug for painful osteoarthritis. Br J Rheumatol. 1994;33:455–460
  19. Lewis D, Lewis B, Sturrock R. Transcutaneous electrical nerve stimulation in osteoarthrosis: a therapeutic alternative?. Ann Rheum Dis. 1984;43:47–49
  20. Lundeberg T. A comparative study of the pain alleviating effect of vibratory stimulation, transcutaneous electrical nerve stimulation, electroacupuncture and placebo. Am J Chin Med. 1984;12:72–79
  21. Machin D, Lewith GT, Wylson S. Pain measurement in randomized clinical trials: a comparison of two pain scales. Clin J Pain. 1988;4:161–168
  22. Marchand S, Charest J, Li J, Chenard JR, Lavignolle B, Laurencelle L. Is TENS purely a placebo effect? A controlled study on chronic low back pain. Pain. 1993;54:99–106
  23. Moore SR, Shurman J. Combined neuromuscular electrical stimulation and transcutaneous electrical nerve stimulation for treatment of chronic back pain: a double-blind, repeated measures comparison. Arch Phys Med Rehabil. 1997;78:55–60
  24. Taylor P, Hallet M, Flaherty L. Treatment of osteoarthritis of the knee with transcutaneous electrical stimulation. Pain. 1981;11:233
  25. Topuz O, Ozfidan E, Ozgen M, Ardic F. Efficacy of transcutaneous electrical nerve stimulation and percutaneous neuromodulation therapy in chronic low back pain. J Back Musculoskel Rehabil. 2004;17:127–133
  26. Weiner D, Rudy T, Glick R. Efficacy of percutaneous electrical nerve stimulation for the treatment of chronic low back pain in older adults. J Am Ger Soc. 2003;51:599–608
  27. Weng C-S, Tsai Y-S, Shu S-H, Chen C-C, Sun M-F. The treatment of upper back pain by two modulated frequency modes of acupuncture-like TENS. J Med Biol Eng. 2005;25:21–25
  28. Yurtkuran M, Kogacil T. TENS, electroacupuncture and ice massage: comparison of treatment for osteoarthritis of the knee. Am J Acupunct. 1999;27:133–140
  29. Zizic TM, Hoffman KC, Holt PA, Hungerford DS, O’Dell JR, Jacobs MA, et al. The treatment of osteoarthritis of the knee with pulsed electrical stimulation. J Rheumatol. 1995;22:1757–1761

PII: S0304-3959(07)00073-5

doi: 10.1016/j.pain.2007.02.007

PAIN
Volume 130, Issue 1 , Pages 157-165 , July 2007

Article Tools

* Image Usage & Resolution